Posts

Showing posts with the label News Analysis

NEWS ANALYSIS -- Political shades of Art

By Kartik Lokhande Of late, the country is talking about a spate in the protests of the kind of returning of awards especially by writers. Some are referring to Dadri lynching incident, some to murder of acclaimed writer M M Kalburgi, and some to secondary political party like Shiv Sena’s diktat forcing cancellation of the concert of Pakistani ghazal maestro Ghulam Ali in Mumbai. Of course, Dadri lynching must be condemned in the harshest words. Of course, Kalburgi’s murder must be denounced. Of course, political party must be criticised for issuing diktat against performance of a popular and eminent artist from Pakistan in India. However, at the same time, one must make an attempt to look into political overtones to the protests especially by artists, and that too, award-winning writers. It all became a talking point in electronic media and activist-media, especially after Nayantara Sahgal, daughter of Vijayalakshmi Pandit (who was sister of India’s first Prime Minist...

NEWS ANALYSIS -- What about affordable education?

  By Kartik Lokhande In the current atmosphere of political hate-mongering and media attention being diverted to high-profile murder mystery, news of Edula Santhosh Reddy’s death has been relegated to national silence. For, his death raises many basic questions that no one is probably willing to find answers to. For those who do not know who Edula Santhosh Reddy is, here is a brief: He was a Class X student studying at a private school at Julapally mandal headquarters in Karimnagar district of Andhra Pradesh. A resident of Abbapur village, he committed suicide as his family was not being able to pay the fees and the school authorities made him stand outside classroom along with some other students for long time. Before ending his life, Edula shot a selfie-video and narrated the entire incident that led him to take the extreme step. Now, this raises an important issue – How to make education affordable to all? At the root of this question is massive commercialization of e...

NEWS ANALYSIS -- Dear Bapu...

By Kartik Lokhande Dear Bapu, As the world and our nation gear up to celebrate your birth anniversary on October 2 later this week, I wish to take the opportunity to write this letter to you. I am a small man, who nurtured a wish to write to you since his teen-age. I wished to share with you, obviously without any expectation of a reply, some thoughts and some questions to which I could not get logical answers till this date. Hence, this letter. Bapu, your biggest gift to mankind was non-violent, peaceful protests. Sadly, they are a rarity today. For, since India gained independence, Governments of the day gradually tended to ignore such protests except when some influential activists were involved. Today, if a common man wants to stage peaceful protest or takes to non-violent agitation to press for his demand, he is simply ignored. Besides, Governments of the day often tend to take cognisance of only violent protests involving burning of tyres, stone-pelting, torching o...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Silencing of the lambs

By Kartik Lokhande  Just 36 months into this world, and Aylan Kurdi became a victim of cruelty of the savages calling themselves humans. The promise with which he must have come into this world, was never realised. The hopes he held in his innocent eyes, drowned in the vast expanse of a conflict and a sea of crisis. The photograph of the body of this little boy washed up on a beach near Turkish resort of Bodrum, shook the human among humans.  Sadly, Aylan is not -- and will not be -- the first victim of a conflict. He became a victim of the crisis in Syria that is a result of the rise of the brutal regime of Islamic State. But, he is not the only child who fell to the conflict imposed by some barbarians in a part of the world. Aylan did not die alone. He died along with his 5-year-old brother Galip, mother, and nine others while trying to cross to Kos, a Greek island, in two small boats that capsized. They were among more than 2,500 died in an attempt to cross to ...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Competing to be Backward

By Kartik Lokhande Years ago, we six were very good friends. We knew each other by name. We knew teachers as only ‘sir’ or ‘madam’. We went to each other’s homes and paid respects in front of image or idol or script of whichever ‘deity’ was there. We participated as volunteers in religious or other programmes in each other’s homes. I remember all of us pooling together Rs 12/- from our ‘birthday reserves’ to buy new text books for a poor friend among us. We were friends in need. We all shared respect for elders and every faith, and every leader whose story was there in our text-books. But, at the end of our school days, everyone started noticing certain things linked to each other’s background social practices. Then, three of us went to the same college. There, ‘certain things’ dominated each other’s observations. There were politically active others also, who expanded the ideas of these ‘certain things’ for different groups. And, when the forms had to be submitted, these ‘ce...

NEWS ANALYSIS: 50 years since...

By Kartik Lokhande   2015 is an important year. For, this is the 50th year since 1965 war between India and Pakistan following the latter’s misadventure. For, it is just short of 50 years since ‘Tashkent Declaration’ signed between the then Prime Minister of India and the then President of Pakistan in Tashkent. For, the year 2015 also witnesses one more instance of India willing to talk to her neighbouring State but the latter insisting on involving non-State actors, a characteristic feature of Pakistan since 1965.   In the year 1965, Pakistan hatched a plan for another misadventure in Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir with an intention to ‘finish the unfinished business of Partition’. Pakistan banked on theory devised by some of her over-enthusiastic and radical military and diplomatic elements that people of Kashmir would side by Pakistan Army. However, under the tough leadership of the then Prime Minister Mr Lal Bahadur Shastri, India gave Pakistan a bloody nose as...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Exhibitionist Patriotism

By Kartik Lokhande It was August 15 th , the Independence Day of the country. It was an occasion for celebration. Hearts filled with pride, children proudly wearing badges bearing shape of India’s map, people thronging ‘happening venues’ to raise slogans loudly and wave as big a flag as possible to prove that their pride was greater than that of others, and such scenes were visible throughout the country. At a traffic signal where vehicles were waiting for the signal to turn green, a van with a national flag mounted atop came blowing horn and youngsters in it shouting ‘Bharat Mata ki Jay’, and zoomed past, jumping the signal that was still red. This scene, too, must have been noticed by countless many across the country. This, is sad reality of the day. No doubt, every Indian should celebrate Independence Day. No doubt, people must wave flags, hoist those, raise slogans, sing patriotic songs, roam around. But, one must not have any doubt in mind that all these things should add...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Let there be heroes in education!

 By Kartik Lokhande July 26, 2015 marked the 16 th anniversary of India’s military triumph over Pakistan in Kargil theatre. Ther were documentaries on television channels, columns full of articles in newspapers and magazines, flood of photographs on websites and social sites, and talk-talk-talk in various corners of the country. All of them in all of these said, all this is aimed at remembering our heroes. But, the pertinent question to ask here is – Do we really want these real-life military heroes to be remembered? The answer to this question is a clear ‘NO’. For, if we as a nation wanted to remember these heroes, hadn’t we made efforts to include their real-life stories of valour in our school and college curricula? Previously, during our school days, we were taught the story of Abdul Hamid, Company Quarter Master Havildar, who had performed super-human act of destroying five Pakistani tanks in the 1965 India-Pakistan war. The martyr finds no place in present-day sc...

News Analysis: Liar’s Rants

By Kartik Lokhande Once again, Pakistan is at it. Being very well aware of its misdeeds, she has now started crying hoarse and hurling utterly false accusations of ‘ceasefire violations’ against a restraining India. Obviously, nobody is inclined to believe Pakistan, which has been habitual about telling lies. The latest incident of Pakistan’s lie standing exposed is that of ‘Indian’ drone shot down near the Line of Control (LoC) in Bhimber area of Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK). Inter Services Public Relations of Pakistan raked up the controversy by issuing a statement that ‘Indian’ drone was brought down as it was doing aerial photography. And, Pakistan’s blatant lie was nailed by none other than her friend China. The People’s Daily run by the ruling Communist Party of China disclosed that the drone shot down by Pakistan was of Chinese make. Deeply embarrassed by this disclosure by China, and sulking over her lie getting exposed internationally, Pakistan resorted...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Waterlogging, urban planning

By Kartik Lokhande Come monsoon, and within first few spells one gets to see a lot of photographs of waterlogged streets in almost every major city in India including the national capital New Delhi. Year after year, this problem is engulfing more number of areas in these ‘urban islands’. The reason? Poor urban planning. What has happened to the cities that have grown leaps and bounds? The cities are becoming the powerhouses of development, capital inflows, investments, job opportunities, high-rises, and pockets attracting migrants from vast rural meadows. With more and more economic activities, many cities are expanding horizontally. However, for want of proper planning, there are not many cities that have come up with ‘walk to work’ units. As a result, most of the cities are witnessing a vertical growth, with more number of high-rise buildings adorning the urban skylines, or, one shall say, choking the view of blue sky. The plots with single-storeyed houses with court...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Reform needed

By Kartik Lokhande “If alternative education must continue, it should be made competitive and practically useful to a student. One can learn to be a good Muslim without going to a madrassa, but one cannot learn Algebra without going to school.” This is the statement from an editorial published in the multi-edition Pakistan-based daily ‘The Nation’ on July 4, 2015, offering comment on the latest decision of Maharashtra Government asking madrassas to teach Science, Mathematics, English, and Social Sciences. Sadly, while this is the comment that Maharashtra Government’s decision has evoked in Muslim-dominated nation like Pakistan, there is much of silly and unfounded debate going on Maharashtra as well as various other parts of India. Let us take a look at the issue. It all started a few days ago with the Maharashtra Government’s decision to treat children taking education in madrassas as ‘out of school’ if the madrassas are not teaching subjects like Scien...

NEWS ANALYSIS: CasteApp, Castebook etc

By Kartik Lokhande Long ago, someone had said that social media will strengthen democracy. While one tends to believe this statement on the basis of positive usages of social media platforms, one is also encouraged to think otherwise because of caste-based usages of the same platforms. In true sense, the platforms like WhatsApp, Facebook etc have turned into tools to deepen the social divides in virtual world. There was a time when the media was controlled by ruling political class. Then, especially during the British Raj, the freedom fighters in India used mainly the print media to express their dissent. When there was no space for expression of dissent in so-called mainstream media, they resorted to starting secret publications devoted to the cause of struggle for Independence. There were instances when radio or television media working from foreign soil became useful platforms for Indian freedom fighters, to make the world know their views. Since India earned her In...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Manifestos, promises, freebies etc

By Kartik Lokhande Electoral reforms have been a topic of continuing debate over the years in India. Sometimes, the issue of funding gets prominence. Sometimes, issues pertaining to manifestos are pushed to centre-stage of debate. However, every time, not much of ‘action’ takes places, except for framing of guidelines. The latest case relates to failure of political parties in fulfilling their pre-poll promises made in their manifestos. In reply to a query made under Right to Information Act, the Election Commission of India (ECI) has made it clear that it has ‘no power’ to take action against political parties failing to deliver on the election promises. Stating that it has framed guidelines to be followed by parties for election manifesto, ECI has ‘urged’ political parties to desist from making ‘such’ commitments. This is not the first time that the issue of political parties failing to keep their promises made to voters during pre-poll campaign, has cropped up. What...

NEWS ANALYSIS: A New Chapter

By Kartik Lokhande The ratification of Land Boundary Agreement of 1974 and the Protocol of 2011 between India and Bangladesh is indeed a new chapter in not only the foreign relations between both the countries but also in India’s external affairs. Prime Minister Mr Narendra Modi and Bangladesh Premier Sheikh Hasina both showed their determination to iron out the issues pertaining to land boundary through expeditious implementation of the historic Land Boundary Agreement (LBA). The agreement has its roots in the partition of India in 1947. Then, Sir Cyril Radcliffe had drawn up a line separating India and Pakistan. Later, this Radcliffe Line became the border between India and liberated East Pakistan now known as Bangladesh. There were issues to be settled and Land Boundary Agreement of 1974 was signed between both the countries. These issued included undemarcated land boundary of 6.1 kms, exchange of enclaves, and ‘adverse possessions’. However, the situation on ground...

NEWS ANALYSIS: Legacy of an Icon

By Kartik Lokhande ‘Bharat Ratna’ Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar is in news again in his 125 th birth anniversary year. In the anniversary celebrations, the political parties have found an ‘opportunity’ to ‘claim’ the legacy of the icon. However, this raises an all important question: Have we, as a nation, understood Dr B R Ambedkar in correct perspective and tried to understand his legacy? The answer, sadly, is not very positive. Dr Ambedkar was a man of rare merit. Among the giants of the time, he must be remembered for spirit of learning, bringing scholarship in the realm of politics, modern outlook, using knowledge of world laws to gift his country with the Constitution of India, openness of mind for studied debate and dialogue, firm commitment to the cause of uplift of downtrodden, strong support for annihilation of caste, political awakening of masses, and vision for economy. Of course, these are broader things. There are a lot many things that one should remember when o...